The Last Ember: fact-check log
Every high-risk number in the book was re-checked against primary or extension sources. This table records what was checked and what changed. 58 entries, updated November 19, 2026. Appendix A7 of the printed book points here.
| Topic | First draft said | Verified / corrected to | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sinking car | Floats 30-120 s; that is the escape window | May float 30 s to minutes, but the realistic exit window is about 1 minute; SWOC protocol; caution on spring-loaded tools | Univ. of Manitoba; NPR; WMS |
| Emergency radio use | "Any person" may use any frequency in an emergency | 47 CFR 97.403 applies to amateur stations; not a general public license | eCFR Part 97 |
| Wood-gas vehicles | About 1 million in WWII Europe | Almost a million gasifiers worldwide (FAO); Germany built 500,000+ by 1945; 1942 production: Germany 155,000, Sweden 73,000, France 65,000 | FAO 1986; Finnish historical tables via Low-Tech Magazine |
| Fog net yield | 3-10 L per m2 per day | Up to about 10 L per m2 per day in peak season; many sites less | Frontiers field study, Atacama 2024-25 |
| NY solar resource | ~4 summer, 2-2.5 December | 4.3-4.7 annual, ~6 July, 2.0-3.1 December | NREL PVWatts v8 |
| Straw bale R-value | R-30+ | Whole-wall tests R-27 to R-31 (ORNL), R-30 (CEC) | ORNL; California Energy Commission |
| Poultry scald | 145-150 F, 30-60 s | 140-150 F; K-State Extension 140 F for 30-40 s | K-State Extension EP71 |
| Game cooling target | (not stated) | Meat at 40 F or below within 24 h; above 40 F, cool the carcass the same day; ice or snow bags in the cavity | Montana State Univ. Extension; Clemson HGIC; Penn State Extension |
| CWD precautions | (not stated) | Gloves; do not eat brain, spinal cord, eyes, spleen, tonsils, lymph nodes; avoid cutting spine or skull; bone out | CDC via MN DNR, TPWD, IN DNR, NY DOH |
| Game bags | (not stated) | Breathable cloth; no airtight bags or tarps on warm meat | Clemson HGIC |
| Sinking car, no window exit | Do not wait to equalize | Equalized door exit is the last resort when windows fail; many drown before the car fills | Univ. of Manitoba (Giesbrecht); IAED |
| Improvised window breakers | Spring-loaded tools can fail | Spring-loaded beat hammer-style (hammers ineffective underwater); headrests and phones ineffective; none broke laminated glass | AAA 2019 escape tool tests |
| Sinking car escape details | Power windows work ~1 min; kick away from car | Power windows unreliable; no suction pulls swimmers down (myth removed) | McDonald and Giesbrecht 2013 |
| Drowning CPR | 5 rescue breaths first | AHA/AAP 2024: 2 breaths first, compressions-only if no breaths; ERC teaches 5; after near-drowning observe 6 h if well, hospital if resuscitated | AHA/AAP 2024; ERC; WMS 2024 |
| Hide clothing and insulation | (not stated) | Fur inside; cattail and milkweed fluff between two layers; leaves/needles/moss sleeping bag; layers; keep dry | Army FM 21-76; NativeTech; Univ. of Nebraska |
| Potassium iodide dose | Take at the dose officials specify | 130/65/32/16 mg by age; teens >=70 kg 130 mg; best <24 h before to 2 h after, up to 8 h; one dose for neonates and pregnant women; 16.25 mg/tsp home mix | FDA 2001 guidance; HHS REMM; WHO 2017 |
| KI from powder | (not stated) | Saturated KI ~1 g/mL (SSKI label strength); 1+7 dilution ~125 mg/mL; nickel = 5.0 g (US Mint); our method, no agency source | SSKI label; KI solubility; US Mint |
| Shelter building figures | (not stated) | Frost depth 42-48 in NE (IRC); wood 8 in+ above soil (NPS); log settling ~3/4 in/ft (InterNACHI, approx); shakes 4:12 min (CSSB); cob walls 10-24 in, 8 in+ above grade (IRC cob); chimney 3-2-10 (IRC R1003.9) | IRC; NPS Brief 26; CSSB; InterNACHI |
| Beekeeping figures | (not stated) | Varroa treat at 2 per 100 bees spring/early summer, 3 per 100 Aug on (HBHC via MSU, UF/IFAS); winter stores one full deep, ~90-100 lb (Cornell); inspection temp ~60 F (approx) | Mississippi State Ext.; UF/IFAS IN1257; Cornell Pollinator Network |
| Calf colostrum | (not stated) | About 3 qt (~10% body weight) within 2 h, second feeding within 6-12 h | Kentucky, Utah State, Wisconsin dairy extension |
| Livestock gestation | (not stated) | Rabbit ~31 d; pig ~114 d; cow ~283 d; dry off 60 d before calving | Extension consensus |
| Magnetic declination, Northeast | (not stated) | About 10-17 deg W (NYC ~13, Boston ~14, N. Maine ~16) | NOAA magnetic field calculator |
| Sundial hour angles 42 N | (not stated) | tan H = sin(lat) x tan(15 deg x h): 10, 21, 34, 49, 68, 90 deg | Standard horizontal-sundial formula (computed) |
| Seawater salt yield | (not stated) | About 35 g per liter; ~3.4-3.5 gal per lb | Ocean salinity ~35 ppt |
| Poultry fasting | 12 h | 6-12 h (UMN Extension: 6-8 h) | Univ. of Minnesota Extension |
| Sauerkraut | 2% salt, 18-22 C, 3-6 wk | 3 Tbsp per 5 lb; 3-4 wk at 70-75 F, 5-6 wk at 60-65 F | Penn State, UNH, Alaska Extension |
| Water-glassed eggs | About a year | 12-18 months reported; not an extension-tested method | Practitioner sources |
| Wet clothing | Loses heat 25x faster | Water conducts heat ~25x better than still air | Physics; corrected wording |
| Suction well pump | Cannot exceed 7.6 m | Practical limit about 7 m; theoretical ~10 m at sea level | Physics |
| Biointensive land need | ~4,000 sq ft per person | Confirmed: ~4,000 sq ft, vegan diet, skilled grower, incl. compost crops | Ecology Action |
| Ground-meat canning | 75 / 90 min at 10 psi weighted | Confirmed (11 psi dial, 0-1,000 ft) | NCHFP / USU / NCSU Extension |
| Canned bacon, bread in jars | Unsafe | Confirmed: no tested process; NCHFP and extension advise against | NCHFP; Clemson; USU; Penn State |
| Generator distance | 20 ft | Confirmed: 20 ft from doors, windows, vents | CDC; CPSC |
| Bleach doses, boil times, SODIS | As printed | Confirmed | EPA; CDC; Eawag |
| Chapter the Medicine, First Aid and Sanitation chapter (medicine) | Basic first-aid outline | Rewritten in full; key figures re-checked live (Nov 2026) against WMS, AHA, CDC, FDA, Cochrane and UK military guidance; tourniquet width and placement, frostbite ibuprofen, spinal care and the hair-apposition trial corrected | See chapter sources |
| Chapter the Plant Medicine of the Northeast chapter (Northeast plant medicine) | Not in first draft | Herb doses checked against EMA monographs; hazards against CDC, IDSA, AAD, Cornell and NY DEC; usnic acid and wintergreen figures rest on secondary sources | See chapter sources |
| Chapter the Evasion, Deception and Hostile People chapter (evasion, deception) | Not in first draft | Re-checked on opened sources (Nov 2026): FBI elicitation brochure (technique names), the seven pre-incident signals, BLISS and TEDD, the negotiation methods, and the 1981 victim-selection study (journal abstract); the gray-man habits are practice advice, not study results | FM 21-76; FBI; study abstracts (OJP, ERIC) |
| Chapter the Poisonous and Edible Wild Plants of the Northeast chapter (do-not-eat plants, berries, mushrooms) | Six look-alike pairs and a table | 38 species in licensed photographs; ID and harm checked live (Nov 2026); unconfirmed toxicity worded as such (privet, porcelain berry, bush honeysuckle) | Go Botany; Cornell; Penn State; NNEPC; NAMA; MushroomExpert; CHOP |
| Moss on the north side | Unreliable; use only to confirm | Kept: moss follows moisture and shade on all sides of a tree | Univ. of Maryland Extension; GVSU |
| Sunrise direction (Ch. the Navigation, Communication and Community chapter) | Roughly east | Due east only at equinoxes; 56-59° (June) to 121-124° (Dec) at 40-45°N, calculated | Formula checked against Griffith Observatory table |
| Shadow-stick wait | 15-30 minutes | 10-15 minutes, until the tip moves a few centimeters; first mark is west | U.S. Army FM 3-25.26 |
| Scavenged medicines (Ch. the Medicine, First Aid and Sanitation chapter) | Shelf-life paragraph only | 26-row table; FDA says no guarantee past expiry; SLEP and 2012 expired-drug data; snippet-only facts marked [approx.] | FDA; 2006 and 2012 expired-drug studies; SLEP per-drug data; NRC |
| Quinzee (Ch. the Shelter: From One Night to Permanent Home chapter) | Vent, shovel inside, marked door | Sinter 1-2 h+; walls 30-60 cm; vent 2.5-10 cm by temperature; no flame inside | NOLS; Appalachian Mountain Club; Minnesota DNR (CO) |
| Pemmican energy | ~3,500 kcal per lb | About 3,000 kcal per lb for a 1:1 meat-fat mix (calculated) | Atwater values |
| Dew collection | About a liter an hour | Heavy dew rarely exceeds 0.5 L per square meter per night | Measured dew yields |
| Haybox fuel saving | Up to 70% | No figure kept: no source found | None found |
| Rabbits as meat animals | Most meat per feed of any livestock | Among the most efficient; broiler chickens equal or beat them on feed | Protein-conversion data |
| Honey per hive | Roughly 30-60 lb per colony in a typical year | Confirmed: US average 48 lb, New York 56 lb (2025) | USDA NASS, March 2026 |
| Declination, Hudson Valley | Roughly 13° W | 12.5-13° W in 2026; changes slowly, check a current value | NOAA World Magnetic Model 2025 |
| Crescent-moon south | Points roughly south | Unreliable; errors of tens of degrees | No authoritative source supports it |
| Halving thicknesses | Steel and water given as ranges; earth and concrete credited to the Oak Ridge manual | Only earth and concrete come from the manual; steel and water given as ranges from military medical manuals and civil-defense tables | Oak Ridge manual 1987; Health Physics Society; NATO FM 8-10-7 Appendix B |
| Protection factors | Large buildings 10-200+ | Large buildings typically 80 (upper floors) to hundreds (basements) | LLNL-TR-684121 (2016) |
| Dried food, canned food | 6-24 months; 12-18 months | 4-12 months (jerky 2 weeks unchilled); about 12 months | NCHFP |
| Long-term storage table | Powdered milk 20 years; rice 20-30 | Replaced with the 2024 BYU shelf-life figures | BYU 2024; Utah State Extension |
| Medicine re-check (Nov 2026) | Various | Urine output 0.5 mL/kg/h; CPR stop rules; sugar 15-20 g; EpiPen color; ORS; bleach and peroxide shelf lives; crush timing | CDC; FDA labels; NIDDK; AAC |
| Fallout decontamination | Five short steps; conditioner rule unsourced | Full steps; conditioner ban credited to HHS REMM (CDC does not state it); pets wash first, brush only if you cannot wash | CDC; FEMA 2024; HHS REMM; Ready.gov |
| Fire-making | Eight methods in a table; four explained | All eight Army-manual methods plus hand drill, pump drill, fire saw, fire thong, fire piston and permanganate, with steps | FM 21-76; FM 3-05.70; AFH 10-644; RSC |
| New sections (Nov 2026) | Not in first draft | The First Week, Electricity and Batteries, distillation, insects, poisoning, small wind and water power: each claim checked on an opened source; rules of thumb marked [approx.] | See each chapter's sources box |